Ranking the Top 15 Serial Killer Shows

Our fascination with serial killers and true crime reflects a deeper curiosity about the darker corners of human nature. This intrigue isnt limited to viewersmany of the detectives, psychologists, and investigators in these shows share the same obsession, navigating morality, trauma, and obsession while facing the worst of humanity. Serial killer series probe existential questions through their characters, leaving audiences in suspense as heroes confront terrifying killers while often struggling to maintain their own sanity. Some series even immerse us in the killers perspective, revealing that evil can manifest in unexpected ways. Heres a curated list of the 15 most compelling serial killer shows of all time.

The Following

Kevin Williamson, known for "Scream" and "Dawson's Creek," ventured into TV crime thrillers with "The Following" in 2013. Kevin Bacon stars as FBI agent Ryan Hardy, tasked with capturing Joe Carroll, a former English professor turned serial killer who inspires a cult of followers. Combining high-octane suspense with gruesome violence, the series blends elements of "The Silence of the Lambs" and "Criminal Minds," offering an intense portrayal of pursuit and obsession.

Marcella

Created by Hans Rosenfeldt, "Marcella" follows Anna Friel as a former London detective returning to the force after a serial killer she once failed to catch resumes killing. Juggling a deteriorating family life and mysterious blackouts, Marcella becomes an unpredictable and gripping protagonist. The series excels at keeping viewers uncertain, blurring the lines between truth and perception.

Millennium

Chris Carters "Millennium" explores darker themes than his previous work, "The X-Files." Lance Henriksen stars as Frank Black, an ex-FBI agent with the uncanny ability to understand killers minds. Consulting for the enigmatic Millennium Group, Black investigates serial killers while grappling with an unrelenting grim reality. Combining surreal visuals with chilling violence, the show remains a unique take on the genre.

Mr. Mercedes

Based on Stephen Kings Bill Hodges trilogy, David E. Kelleys "Mr. Mercedes" stars Brendan Gleeson as retired detective Bill Hodges. Haunted by an unsolved massacre, Hodges faces a relentless killer who taunts him, blending dark humor with tension. The series emphasizes character depth alongside a compelling cat-and-mouse narrative.

American Horror Story: Asylum

The second season of Ryan Murphys anthology series immerses viewers in Briarcliff Manor, where journalist Lana Winters uncovers the asylums dark secrets. Kit Walker is accused of being the elusive killer Bloody Face, while Sister Jude (Jessica Lange) rules with fear. The season balances supernatural hints with psychological horror, culminating in a shocking reveal that keeps viewers enthralled.

Bates Motel

A contemporary prequel to Hitchcocks "Psycho," "Bates Motel" explores the complex relationship between Norman (Freddie Highmore) and Norma Bates (Vera Farmiga). Mental instability, violent incidents, and family trauma shape Normans descent into darkness. Exceptional performances bring emotional depth to the story, making it both gripping and psychologically rich.

Luther

Idris Elba stars as DCI John Luther, an obsessive detective confronting horrific crimes while forming an unusual bond with genius psychopath Alice Morgan (Ruth Wilson). The show combines violent crime cases with psychological exploration, questioning morality and the nature of evil through a compelling detective-psychopath dynamic.

True Detective

The first season of Nic Pizzolattos HBO anthology series follows detectives Rust Cohle (Matthew McConaughey) and Marty Hart (Woody Harrelson) as they revisit a series of murders spanning over 15 years. Told non-linearly, the series weaves philosophical themes into crime investigation, marked by striking cinematography and masterful direction.

Criminal Minds

As the longest-running serial killer show, "Criminal Minds" established the genres conventions. The FBIs Behavioral Analysis Unit profiles serial offenders, with a team of memorable characters including Aaron Hotchner, Derek Morgan, Spencer Reid, JJ Jareau, and Penelope Garcia. The mix of procedural storytelling and character dynamics keeps viewers engaged season after season.

Ill Be Gone in the Dark

This true-crime series, based on Michelle McNamaras book, chronicles her investigation into the Golden State Killer. By centering the victims and McNamaras personal journey, the show avoids sensationalism while highlighting the persistence and humanity behind solving real-life cases.

Hannibal

NBCs "Hannibal" reimagines Thomas Harris iconic characters. Will Graham (Hugh Dancy), a profiler who empathizes with killers, forms a dangerous relationship with the cannibalistic psychiatrist Hannibal Lecter (Mads Mikkelsen). The series blends psychological tension, artistry, and gore, anchored by brilliant performances and a unique storytelling approach.

Dexter

"Dexter" offers a rare perspective by making a serial killer the protagonist. Michael C. Halls Dexter Morgan works as a blood spatter analyst while secretly targeting criminals who escape justice. The show explores the tension between morality and instinct, balancing dark thrills with emotional depth through Dexters relationships.

Mindhunter

David Finchers "Mindhunter" follows the early days of the FBIs Behavioral Analysis Unit. Agents Holden Ford (Jonathan Groff) and Bill Tench (Holt McCallany), along with psychologist Wendy Carr (Anna Torv), interview infamous serial killers to understand their psychology. Detailed performances and Finchers signature visual style elevate this series into a meticulous and haunting exploration of criminal minds.

Sharp Objects

Based on Gillian Flynns novel, "Sharp Objects" stars Amy Adams as journalist Camille Preaker, who returns to her hometown to investigate the murder of two young girls. Alongside confronting her traumatic past, Camille uncovers dark secrets within her family. Exceptional acting and Valles direction make this miniseries a psychologically riveting experience with a shocking final twist.

The Fall

BBCs "The Fall" features Gillian Anderson as Detective Superintendent Stella Gibson, overseeing a serial killer case in Belfast. Facing the calculating Paul Spector (Jamie Dornan), Stella combines empathy for victims with unflinching professionalism. The show stands out for its portrayal of a strong female lead navigating complex moral terrain while pursuing a relentless killer.

Author: Logan Reeves